MATHERS BRIDGE RESTAURANT
A Pleasant Merritt Island Memory
By Mike Miller Updated November 1, 2024
The Mathers Bridge Restaurant was near the south end of Merritt Island at the west end of the Mathers Bridge that connects the island to Indian Harbour Beach.
It was demolished for economic reasons in 1992.
Nothing remains now except for a vacant lot; it is owned by Brevard County and may become a park in the future.
The lot is too small for there to ever be another restaurant on the property; it would not be able to meet code for the required number of parking spaces.
Mathers Bridge in 1926
The restaurant was a favorite of locals and tourists alike and operated for 52 years before it finally had to close.
The restaurant was Old Florida, with most of its dining taking place out on a wooden deck overlooking the Banana River.
The deck was usually shared with raccoons and cats, permanent residents who liked the easy food gathering of the food scraps that fell through the gaps in the deck.
Mathers Bridge Old Waterwheel by Lloyd Behrendt
In the early days of the restaurant, the outside of the place was also enhanced with a beat-up old waterwheel near the bridge that had no historical significance but looked like it belonged there.
There were only 17 parking spaces in front of the Mathers Bridge Restaurant, so people quite often parked along the road in Indian Harbour Beach and walked across the bridge to reach the place.
Mathers Bridge Restaurant Dining Deck
A lot of other people, including me, used to come by boat and try to grab a berth alongside the rickety dock.
Food was simple but enhanced by the atmosphere. Fish and chips, shrimp baskets, hamburgers, hot dogs, cold beer.
Mathers Bridge in Modern Times
It was hard to beat sitting in the sun and enjoying your food and beer and watching the parade of boats churning by and the frequent openings of the Mathers Bridge swing span letting the bigger boats go through.
It wasn’t a trendy place like Shooters, where the beautiful people gather to show off their abs and bikinis; it was a family place and attracted an eclectic mix of people: young and old, rich and poor, beautiful and ugly.
The outside walls were decorated in colorful painted murals of fish; the fish were labeled with their biological names as well as the name the fish went by locally.
Mathers Bridge Restaurant by Lloyd Behrendt
They did not like the traffic congestion caused by the shortage of parking, and they did not like the sound of music on the deck and the laughter of people having fun.
I really don’t blame them, but their complaints had political power. The government began doing what it does best; making it harder and harder for the restaurant to survive until it finally had to close.
I first visited Mathers Bridge Restaurant in 1966, and last visited it just before it closed in 1992. So, I should stop whining and be thankful for the 26 years I was able to enjoy it.
But I can’t help wishing it still stood there and was serving those simple meals.
And what happened to the raccoons and cats?
Annie the Dragon, by Lloyd Behrendt
Just a few hundred feet south of the old restaurant stood another iconic South Merritt Island Landmark: Annie the Dragon.
She crumbled with time and hurricanes. We all hope she will be replaced by a clone in the future.
The paintings of the waterwheel and restaurant at the Mathers Bridge are by Brevard County artist, Lloyd Behrendt. These paintings are available by contacting Lloyd at his website.
February 9, 2021
The History of the Mathers Bridge
by Mike Miller
This Florida Today clipping from 2001 tells the story of the man who built the original Mathers bridge.
